You're right that high elf gets a cantrip and that could provide some interesting possibilities... Although I think that's most likely gonna be for who-ever is up next- (I'll donate two points if we're gonna try and do the group funding thing again... Maybe more if it turns out to be taking a long time, but now first thing I want to do is save some up for a rainy day.) Looks like whoever I'm gonna be is gonna be a (super) melee fighter of some form.
Also with the note of forest elves, I think for option 2 it would be a better choice over a regular elf- "Mask of the wild" would also give option 2 some stealth capabilities, something option 1 is quite evidently gonna be incapable of.
Speaking about the selection, I am myself trying to stay mostly neutral on it even though I technically have "4 votes"... Since the whole idea is "these are four characters that seem interesting to me, you guys pick." And the idea so far seems to currently be to definitely pick one of the two combat oriented characters. Any preference? It basically seems "raw strength vs strength+utility" (I think I am personally currently preferring myself to the elf... Has nothing to do with being at range and shooting stuff means less chance to get yourself killed.

You have any preference or suggestions Spider? You're a "major shareholder" what with also contributing 4 votes, so want to make sure your opinion is heard for sure.